Email us Call us

36 Hamilton Street

4 Beds 3 Baths 3,000 Sq.Ft.


Welcome to this meticulously designed gem nestled in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. Combining two historic houses into one seamless haven of modern luxury, this property effortlessly blends contemporary features with timeless charm while preserving the historic integrity of the original 1800s homes. Step through the entrance gate into the private courtyard and open the door. You'll immediately notice the level of design and beautiful finishes everywhere. To the right, the north wing holds a custom eat-in kitchen with Belgian blue stone flooring, marble countertops, Viking appliances, and elegant brass finishes. A breakfast table with banquette invites casual dining, and for more formal occasions, there's a butler's pantry and dining room with a fireplace. Three bedrooms are in this wing: a first-floor en-suite guest bedroom with outdoor access and two guest bedrooms on the second floor, all providing complete privacy. In the south wing, you'll find a bright, expansive living room with a fireplace, and a bar nestled behind a secret door. There's also a chic office for all your work-from-home needs. On the second floor is a full-floor primary suite, featuring a stunning Viola marble vanity and shower, and a classic claw-foot tub for indulgent relaxation. Outside, a captivating oasis awaits, complete with an outdoor kitchen, dining courtyard, lounge area, outdoor shower, and even a heated saltwater pool, alongside a breathtaking tree that acts as a centerpiece for summer entertaining. This incredibly unique jewel box is close enough to the Village and all that it offers. You won't need a car - but just in case, the property has off-street parking and ample street parking too.

Share Property


36 Hamilton Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963


For Sale

Property Video

Check out our tour of this property.

Features & Amenities


Total Bedrooms 4
Total Bathrooms 3
Full Bathrooms 3
Kitchen Eat-In, Radiant Heated Floor, Belgian Limestone Floors, Marble Countertops
Laundry Room First Floor
Flooring Hardwood, Stone, Radiant Heated
Fireplace 2
Appliances Viking Range, Viking Dishwasher
Other Interior Features Renovated 2022


Water Source Municipal
POOL Heated, Gunite, Salt Water, 12'x18', Propane Heat
ROOF Cedar
Parking Driveway
Heat type Forced Air, Natural Gas
Air Conditioning Central, 4-Zone
Sewer Private
Security Features Alarm
Other Exterior Features Outdoor Shower, Irrigation System

Area & Lot

Status For Sale
LOT SIZE 0.13 Acres
MLS® ID 909925
Type Residential
Year Built 1896
Neighborhood Sag Harbor
Architecture Styles Colonial


SALES PRICE $4,250,000


Mala Sander

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

With 20+ years of experience, Mala Sander is the ultimate expert in buying and selling property in the Hamptons. She is consistently one of the top agents on the East End by sales and transaction volume, in the top 1% of Corcoran agents nationwide, and ranked in the elite group of the top agents in the country by RealTrends and The Wall Street Journal. She has been recognized as a member of Corcoran’s President’s Council every year since 2015, and is a member of the International Luxury Alliance, an exclusive network of top producing real estate agents from North America and Europe. She takes pride in the relationships she forms with her clients, many of who have become repeat customers and friends.

Attached files

Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor

A beautiful bayside village known for a breezy boating culture and a rich whaling history, art galleries and luxury yachts, paddle boarding and high-end dining, Victorian homes and tennis – Sag Harbor has it all. This well-rounded town is a quaint, unpretentious village with an inclusive atmosphere and year-round community. Also a culinary showstopper with a chic selection of stylish boutiques and an artistic influence.

Read more

Work With Us

We work with all kinds of clients helping put together the pieces of their unique puzzles, whether that means downsizing or upsizing, buying or selling, for everyone from Hamptons locals to household names from all walks of life.


Follow US On Instagram