Email us Call us

23 Tyndall Road

5 Beds 3.5 Baths 3,800 Sq.Ft.


Nestled down a private drive, this southwest-facing waterfront oasis offers panoramic views of Noyac Bay with beautiful sunsets all summer long. Just minutes from Sag Harbor Village, the home boasts old-world charm with shade trees, gardens, a tennis court, a heated pool, and a dock for sitting and watching sunsets or launching paddleboards into the creek. The home features multiple living spaces, a renovated kitchen, and a formal dining room, all with water views. The screened porch is the perfect way to escape the elements, and your preferred guests will enjoy the first-floor guest wing, offering complete privacy. Upstairs, you'll find the primary suite and three additional guest bedrooms with incredible views of the grounds. Enjoy kayaking on Polles Creek from the dock, bike to nearby beaches, and farm stands. Sag Harbor Village with marinas, restaurants, shops, and theater is just a mile away, and you're also super close to Shelter Island. The rest of the Hamptons are minutes away on back roads. This exceptional property promises an authentic summer vacation filled with unforgettable moments.


August-Labor Day $75K

September-October $70K

September $35K

October $35K


Share Property


23 Tyndall Road, Sag Harbor 11963


For Rent (Aug-Oct)

Property Video

Check out our tour of this property.

Features & Amenities


Total Bedrooms 5
Total Bathrooms 3.5
Full Bathrooms 3
Half Bathrooms 1
Fireplace 4


Stories 2
POOL Solar Heated, Gunite
Parking Circular Driveway
Air Conditioning Central
Other Exterior Features Tennis

Area & Lot

Status For Rent (Aug-Oct)
LOT SIZE 2.5 Acres
MLS® ID 530659
Year Built 1905
Neighborhood Sag Harbor
View Description Waterfront, Sunset, Southwest


Lease Price $145,000/


Mala Sander

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

With 20+ years of experience, Mala Sander is the ultimate expert in buying and selling property in the Hamptons. She is consistently one of the top agents on the East End by sales and transaction volume, in the top 1% of Corcoran agents nationwide, and ranked in the elite group of the top agents in the country by RealTrends and The Wall Street Journal. She has been recognized as a member of Corcoran’s President’s Council every year since 2015, and is a member of the International Luxury Alliance, an exclusive network of top producing real estate agents from North America and Europe. She takes pride in the relationships she forms with her clients, many of who have become repeat customers and friends.
Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor

A beautiful bayside village known for a breezy boating culture and a rich whaling history, art galleries and luxury yachts, paddle boarding and high-end dining, Victorian homes and tennis – Sag Harbor has it all. This well-rounded town is a quaint, unpretentious village with an inclusive atmosphere and year-round community. Also a culinary showstopper with a chic selection of stylish boutiques and an artistic influence.

Read more

Work With Us

We work with all kinds of clients helping put together the pieces of their unique puzzles, whether that means downsizing or upsizing, buying or selling, for everyone from Hamptons locals to household names from all walks of life.


Follow US On Instagram