Email us Call us
Properties

9 Sag Harbor Rentals without the Village Price Tag

Are you looking for a dreamy Sag Harbor getaway without breaking the bank? Look no further! Here are nine incredible rental properties that offer all the convenience and charm of Sag Harbor without the hefty price tag of staying right in the village. 

 

Are you looking for a dreamy Sag Harbor getaway without breaking the bank? Look no further! Here are nine incredible rental properties that offer all the convenience and charm of Sag Harbor without the hefty price tag of staying right in the village.

 

Here are nine incredible rental properties that offer all the convenience and charm of Sag Harbor without the hefty price tag of staying right in the village. 

 

 

1. 28 Cliff Drive

Nestled in the Bay Point community, this coastal cottage offers 3 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and a fully furnished interior. Renovated to perfection, highlights include Fisher Paykel appliances, radiant heat flooring, and a heated pool/hot tub. Plus, it's just around the corner from Long Beach and Sag Harbor Village

 

 

2.  41 Rawson Road

 

Step into luxury at this beautiful 4-bedroom bayfront home with access to a residents-only beach. Enjoy summer entertaining with ample outdoor space, including a pool, screened porch, and manicured grounds. Plus, it's just minutes away from golf courses and ocean beaches.

 

 

3.  86 Harbor Drive

 

This newly renovated bayfront home boasts 4 beds, 5 bathrooms, and a quiet cul-du-sac location. With its open floor plan, expansive outdoor dining areas, and private dock accommodating up to a 25' boat, you'll have everything you need for a stylish summer escape. Plus, it's just 2 miles from Sag Harbor and just a few miles to ocean beaches.

 

 

4.  54 Brandywine Drive

 

Tucked away in a quiet cul-de-sac, this 4-bed, 4.5-bath home is perfect for hosting friends and family. Highlights include a living area with fireplace, first and second-floor master suites, and a safety-fenced heated pool. Havens Beach is just a stone's throw away, offering sandy shores and calm bay waters.

 

 

5.  1345 Millstone

 

Situated between Sag Harbor Bay Beaches and Bridgehampton Village, this charming 3-bedroom cottage offers privacy and convenience. Highlights include a heated pool, chef's kitchen, and expansive outdoor entertaining spaces.

 

 

6.  26 Whalers Drive

 

Escape to this spacious, newly renovated home located just beyond Sag Harbor Village. With 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and access to miles of hiking trails in the Long Pond Preserve, it's the perfect summer retreat.

 

 

7.  50 Harbor Drive

 

Enjoy bay views from nearly every room in this 4-bed, 3-bath traditional home. Located in Bay Point, this retreat features a well-equipped kitchen, dining patio with grill, outdoor shower, and fire pit. With its proximity to Long Beach and the village, it's one of the best values in Sag Harbor.

 

 

8.  61 Noyac Bay Avenue

 

This waterfront home on Noyack Bay offers breathtaking sunset views and direct beach access. With 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a spacious yard, it's the perfect spot for summer relaxation.

 

 

9.  39 Meredith Avenue

 

Experience the ultimate Sag Harbor Village lifestyle in this brand-new 5-bed, 6-bath home. With deeded access to a private bay beach, a heated pool, and a finished lower level for entertainment, this rental has it all.

 

Whether you're seeking waterfront views, serene surroundings, or close proximity to village amenities, these Sag Harbor rentals offer the perfect blend of luxury and affordability. Don't miss out on your chance to experience the magic of Sag Harbor this summer!

 

Click here to view all Mala Sander+Team's rental offerings or reach out directly to have us send you a tailored selection based on your personal criteria.

Work With Us

We work with all kinds of clients helping put together the pieces of their unique puzzles, whether that means downsizing or upsizing, buying or selling, for everyone from Hamptons locals to household names from all walks of life.

CONTACT US