Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Properties

8 Sag Harbor Village Rentals for a Care-Free (or Car-Free) Summer!

Sag Harbor stands out in the Hamptons with its quaint charm and bustling village life.  From the incredible year-round community and unmatched density of incredible restaurants and local businesses to the historic architecture and best marinas in the entire Northeast, it is the epitome of a perfect summer retreat. Sag offers a unique blend of historic elegance and modern amenities, all accessible without a car.

 

If you're dreaming of a car-free and care-free summer, we've curated a list of 8 stunning rental properties in Sag Harbor Village that promise an unforgettable experience.

 

 

Bright bedroom with white decor, a large bed, and sliding doors leading to a balcony.

 

1.  14 Rogers Street

 

Luxurious and spacious, this 5-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom home offers the pinnacle of village living. With a custom Ornare kitchen and a private backyard oasis, entertaining is effortless. Plus, with Sag Harbor village just a short distance away, you'll have easy access to all its amenities.



 

Cozy lounge area with leather chairs, a black fireplace, and a brick accent wall.

 

2.  136 Jermain Avenue

 

Indulge in luxury at this newly renovated residence boasting 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and three levels of contemporary chic. From the elegant interiors to the outdoor pool and pool house, every detail is designed for relaxation and entertainment.

 

 

Modern kitchen with dark cabinets, open shelving, and a large window over a farmhouse sink.

 

3.  16 Jefferson Street

 

Step back in time at this charming 1790s Whaler's Cottage, updated with Scandinavian design and modern conveniences. With off-street parking and proximity to village shops and restaurants, it's the perfect blend of charm and convenience.

 

 

Living room with gray armchairs, a beige sofa, and colorful pillows and wall art.

 

4.  58 Howard Street

 

Step into a fairytale setting at this meticulously renovated 3-bedroom, 4-bathroom home on Howard Street. Original details blend seamlessly with modern conveniences, offering a tranquil escape just moments from Main Street.

 

 

Two-story white house with a backyard pool, patio, and outdoor dining area

 

5. 31 Meadowlark Lane

 

Brand new construction meets village convenience in this 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom home. With smart house automation and a private backyard complete with a heated pool and pool cabana, summer living has never been easier.

 

 

Historic white house with dormer windows, brick accents, and a green metal roof over the entrance.

 

6.  11 Madison Street, #1

 

Experience quintessential village life in this 2-bedroom apartment nestled within a beautifully restored historic building. Enjoy the charm of Main Street living with modern comforts and your own private patio retreat.

 

 

Bright living room with a white fireplace, beige sofa, and large windows with green views.

 

7.  42 Archibald Way

 

This 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. With a brand new heated pool, spacious backyard, and proximity to nature trails and village amenities, it's an ideal summer getaway.

 

 

Cottage-style house with weathered wood siding, white trim, and manicured bushes.

 

8.  170 Division Street

 

Escape to this beautifully updated historic home offering 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and three fully finished levels of amenities. From the open floor plan to the spacious yard and wooden deck, every detail invites relaxation and enjoyment.



With these Sag Harbor Village rentals, your car-free and care-free summer awaits.

 

Explore the village, relax by the pool, and create memories to last a lifetime in this idyllic Hamptons destination.

 

Click here to view all Mala Sander+Team's rental offerings or reach out directly to have us send you a tailored selection based on your personal criteria.

Work With Us

We work with all kinds of clients helping put together the pieces of their unique puzzles, whether that means downsizing or upsizing, buying or selling, for everyone from Hamptons locals to household names from all walks of life.

CONTACT US