Email us Call us

238 Madison Street

238 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

238 Madison Street

Featured on the cover of Hamptons Cottages & Gardens in July, 2021, every detail has been carefully considered in this idyllic Sag Harbor home. Built in the 1890s and beautifully restored and updated with every modern amenity by the architect and fashion designer owners, thoughtful and meticulous finishes, reclaimed oak floors, and impeccable woodwork. The public rooms include an intimate living room with a fireplace, a dining room fully paneled with beautiful custom wood bookshelves, and a sun-drenched family room with a second fireplace. French doors open to a stone patio with a double barbecue station and sitting area. The gourmet kitchen boasts a La Cornue range, high-end appliances, and modern stainless steel cabinetry juxtaposed with marble countertops. There's also a wine refrigerator and a full-sized washer/dryer. The second floor has a serene owner's suite has a generously sized sleeping area, a marble-floored bathroom with a claw foot bathtub, a separate glass enclosed shower, and a sitting room with double French doors that overlook the gunite pool and garden below. Two charming and sunlit bedrooms (one with 4 bunk beds) and a guest bathroom complete the 3 bedroom layout. Outside, the beautifully landscaped yard is terraced and outlined with stonewalls and boxwood hedges. A 10 foot wooden barn table for 12 sits under a bamboo pergola and is the perfect spot to enjoy a relaxed summer meal. The charming pool house with a hammock and bean bag furniture that spills out onto the grass is a perfect place to relax poolside during the day and it also converts into an outdoor theatre in the evenings with a projector that plays movies on the back wall. This village home is situated in the historic neighborhood just a stone's throw to Sag Harbor Village restaurants, boutiques, and marina and 5 +/- miles to Ocean beaches. It has been beautifully designed for a gracious and easy living making it the perfect Hamptons rental.



July $75K

Two Weeks $40K

Mala Sander Contact
Kyle Koz Contact
  • For Rent (July) Status

  • 3 Beds

  • 2.5 Baths

  • 1,346 Sq.Ft. Area

  • 1890 Year Built

Features & Amenities


Total Bedrooms 3
Total Bathrooms 2.5
Full Bathrooms 2
Half Bathrooms 1
Fireplace 2


POOL Gunite

Area & Lot

Status For Rent (July)
LOT SIZE 0.14 Acres
MLS ID 876993
Year Built 1890
Neighborhood Sag Harbor


Sag Harbor

A beautiful bayside village known for a breezy boating culture and a rich whaling history, art galleries and luxury yachts, paddle boarding and high-end dining, Victorian homes and tennis – Sag Harbor has it all. This well-rounded town is a quaint, unpretentious village with an inclusive atmosphere and year-round community. Also a culinary showstopper with a chic selection of stylish boutiques and an artistic influence.

Read more

Work With Us

We work with all kinds of clients helping put together the pieces of their unique puzzles, whether that means downsizing or upsizing, buying or selling, for everyone from Hamptons locals to household names from all walks of life.


Follow US On Instagram